Fantasy Football Week 3: When to Drop or Hold on to Struggling Players

Week 3 is a critical point for fantasy football managers deciding whether to drop or keep struggling players. The article examines recent performances of Kyle Pitts, Justin Herbert, Marvin Harrison Jr., and Travis Etienne Jr., offering guidance on patience versus trade or release. It also highlight…

By Felo News Desk · Published Sat, 26 Sep 2026 05:06:21 GMT

Week 3 of the NFL season has proven to be the real test for fantasy football managers. While early games often generate panic, it is the third week that reveals whether a player’s struggles are a temporary blip or a sign of deeper issues. This article dives into the latest performances of key players—Kyle Pitts, Justin Herbert, Marvin Harrison Jr., and Travis Etienne Jr.—and offers actionable advice on whether to hold on or make a move.

Kyle Pitts: The Unloved Receiver in a New System

Kyle Pitts Jr. has been a thorn in many fantasy managers’ sides. After a lackluster first two weeks, his Week 3 outing was even more disappointing: a single 5‑yard catch, despite the return of quarterback Michael Penix Jr. to the Arizona Cardinals offense. The Cardinals’ offensive coordinator, Mike McDaniel, is known for creating vertical passing opportunities, but Pitts has yet to find a rhythm in the system. Managers are now at a crossroads: keep him in hope of a breakout or drop him for a more reliable option.

Justin Herbert: Patience Pays Off in a High‑Powered Offense

Justin Herbert’s early season struggles have rattled some fantasy rosters, but the Chargers’ offense remains one of the most potent in the league. Under offensive coordinator Mike McDaniel, the team has a proven playbook that balances short passes with deep throws. The key to Herbert’s success lies in the surrounding weapons—tight ends, receivers, and a solid offensive line. While transition periods can be rough, the talent pool and coaching staff suggest that Herbert’s value will rebound. Fantasy owners should consider holding onto Herbert rather than selling low on a top‑tier quarterback.

Marvin Harrison Jr.: Coaching Frustration Signals a Drop Candidate?

Arizona Cardinals head coach Mike LaFleur has openly expressed frustration with rookie wide receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. During a recent interview, LaFleur suggested that the team should focus on “easy completions” to give Harrison a chance to develop. He also highlighted the presence of other receivers like Trey McBride and Kendrick, implying that Harrison’s role may be limited. If Harrison fails to show improved effort or target conversion in upcoming games, fantasy managers should consider dropping him before his value deteriorates further.

Travis Etienne Jr.: A Bust in a Mismatched Scheme

Travis Etienne Jr. has struggled to find his footing in the Saints’ offense under head coach Kellen Moore. The scheme demands quick decision‑making and versatility in both the passing and running game—skills that Etienne has yet to fully demonstrate. Moreover, the Saints have been favoring veteran Alvin Kamara for high‑value touches, which caps Etienne’s fantasy floor and ceiling. Fantasy owners should explore trade partners who still believe in Etienne’s name value before his usage declines. If a trade cannot be secured, releasing him may be the best option to free up roster space for a more productive running back.

Making the Hard Moves Early

The fantasy season moves fast, and managers who wait too long risk falling into a deeper hole. While it’s normal to start 0‑2, the goal is to avoid a prolonged slump. By making tough decisions early—whether dropping a player, trading, or holding on with confidence—owners can keep their teams competitive. The key is to base moves on player performance, coaching signals, and system fit rather than on short‑term hype.

Conclusion: Patience vs. Action in Fantasy Football

Week 3 serves as a litmus test for many fantasy managers. Players like Kyle Pitts and Marvin Harrison Jr. may warrant a release if they continue to underperform, while Justin Herbert and Travis Etienne Jr. require a more nuanced approach. By staying informed about coaching comments, offensive schemes, and player development, managers can make smarter decisions that set the stage for a successful season.

Key facts

Week 3 is the true test for fantasy players’ performance.
Kyle Pitts’ lack of production signals a potential drop.
Justin Herbert’s talent and offensive system suggest patience is wise.
Marvin Harrison Jr.’s limited role and coaching frustration hint at a drop.
Travis Etienne Jr. is mismatched to the Saints’ scheme and may be a trade target.
Early hard moves keep teams competitive and prevent deep slumps.

Why it matters

Decisions made after Week 3 can set the trajectory of a fantasy season. Holding onto a struggling player may cost points, while dropping a player too early can leave a roster vulnerable when the player rebounds.