Andy Robertson defends Manchester City players amid FFP scandal

Former Liverpool defender Andy Robertson has publicly stated that Manchester City players should not be penalised with trophy removal after the club was found guilty of multiple Premier League financial fair play breaches. Robertson, who played against City for nine years, emphasised that the playe…

By Felo News Desk · Published Sat, 26 Sep 2026 01:20:19 GMT

During a flight from a training camp in Spain to Slovenia with the Scotland squad, former Liverpool defender Andy Robertson was confronted with breaking news: Manchester City had been found guilty of multiple breaches of the Premier League’s financial fair play rules. The Scottish captain, who spent nine seasons battling City’s side at Anfield, was taken aback by the timing of the announcement, which arrived just as he was preparing for a Nations League match against Slovenia in Ljubljana.

City’s Financial Fair Play Verdict

The Premier League’s investigation into City’s spending revealed a pattern of alleged violations, ranging from inflated player wages to questionable transfer fees. The league’s sanctions could include hefty fines, transfer bans, and the controversial possibility of retroactive trophy removal. While the club has indicated its intention to appeal any guilty verdict, the prospect of stripping City of their recent silverware has sparked intense debate across the football community.

Robertson’s Perspective on Player Accountability

When asked about the potential punishment, Robertson made it clear that he believes the players should not bear the brunt of the club’s administrative missteps. "For me, the players showed they were good enough on the pitch," he said. "I don’t know too much about the charges and stuff like that. But they had an incredible team, one that I loved battling against. I don’t think when it comes to these things that players are ever to blame. That’s all I can focus on."

Robertson’s stance is rooted in his long experience on the field. Over his career, he faced City’s midfield maestros and defensive stalwarts, witnessing firsthand the quality of their performances. He argues that the merit of a trophy should be judged by the skill and effort displayed during matches, not by off‑pitch controversies that involve ownership and financial management.

Reactions from the Football Community

Not everyone shares Robertson’s view. Liverpool’s former manager Jürgen Klopp, who has long been a vocal critic of City’s dominance, reportedly joked that he would throw a party if the club’s trophies were taken away. Klopp’s comments underscore the deep divisions within the Premier League, where rival clubs and their supporters often see the financial regulations as a tool to level the playing field.

Meanwhile, City’s own fans and players are divided. Some argue that the club’s success is built on a strong business model that should be protected, while others feel that the club’s ownership has overstepped the boundaries set by the league. The potential for trophy removal has raised questions about precedent and fairness, prompting calls for clearer guidelines from the Premier League.

What Happens Next?

City is expected to lodge an appeal against the guilty verdict, a process that could take several months. During this period, the Premier League will likely keep the club’s current honours intact, pending the outcome of the appeal. If the appeal is unsuccessful, the league may impose sanctions ranging from fines to the removal of trophies, though the latter remains a contentious option.

For Robertson, the upcoming Nations League match against Slovenia is a personal milestone. He will earn his 98th cap for Scotland, moving just four appearances shy of the record held by Kenny Dalglish. The match, scheduled for Saturday, will provide a chance for the former Liverpool defender to focus on his national team duties while the City controversy unfolds.

In the broader context, the City FFP case highlights the growing scrutiny over financial practices in football. As clubs seek to balance competitive ambition with regulatory compliance, the debate over player accountability versus club ownership responsibility will likely intensify.

Ultimately, Robertson’s position reminds fans that on‑field excellence should not be eclipsed by off‑pitch controversies. Whether the Premier League ultimately chooses to strip City of its trophies remains to be seen, but the conversation around fairness, accountability, and the spirit of competition will continue to shape the narrative.

Key facts

Manchester City found guilty of multiple financial fair play breaches
Potential sanctions include fines, transfer bans, and trophy removal
Andy Robertson defends players, stating they should not be punished
Liverpool’s Klopp joked about celebrating trophy removal
City intends to appeal the verdict
Scotland captain Robertson set to earn 98th cap against Slovenia

Why it matters

The debate touches on the core principles of sporting integrity and fairness, questioning whether a club’s administrative actions should influence the legacy of its players.

Frequently asked questions

What are financial fair play rules?

Financial fair play (FFP) rules are regulations designed to prevent football clubs from spending beyond their means, ensuring financial sustainability and fair competition.

Can a club have its trophies removed?

Yes, under certain circumstances the Premier League can order the removal of trophies if a club is found guilty of serious breaches, but this is rare and highly controversial.